8+ Colleges That Accept a 3.5 GPA: Your Options


8+ Colleges That Accept a 3.5 GPA: Your Options

A grade level common of three.5, on a 4.0 scale, represents a B+ common. This educational achievement degree opens doorways to a variety of upper training establishments. Many universities and schools contemplate a 3.5 GPA aggressive for admission, indicating robust educational efficiency throughout secondary training. For instance, a pupil with this GPA could also be thought of an appropriate candidate for state universities, liberal arts schools, and even some extra selective personal establishments.

A 3.5 GPA demonstrates a constant dedication to research and a capability to carry out nicely throughout completely different educational topics. Traditionally, such a GPA has been a benchmark for school readiness, signaling to admissions committees that the applicant possesses the foundational data and work ethic wanted to reach undergraduate research. The good thing about reaching this GPA is the expanded vary of school decisions accessible, probably main to raised academic alternatives and profession prospects.

Understanding which schools particularly contemplate candidates with this educational standing requires exploring components past simply the GPA itself. The next dialogue will delve into the nuances of school admissions, together with the significance of standardized take a look at scores, extracurricular actions, and the general energy of the applicant pool at varied establishments. Moreover, the influence of a pupil’s chosen main and the competitiveness of particular educational applications can be examined.

1. State Universities

State universities symbolize a major section of upper training establishments that continuously admit college students with a 3.5 GPA. These universities, usually funded and operated by state governments, serve a big and various pupil physique, usually prioritizing accessibility for residents of the state. A 3.5 GPA usually falls inside the center 50% vary of admitted college students at many state universities, making it a aggressive, although not essentially assured, admission criterion. The connection lies in the truth that state universities, whereas upholding educational requirements, usually purpose to offer alternatives for a broad spectrum of academically certified college students inside their state. As an illustration, a pupil with a 3.5 GPA making use of to a state college in a much less aggressive state might have a considerably increased likelihood of admission in comparison with a pupil with the identical GPA making use of to a flagship state college in a extremely aggressive state like California or Texas.

The influence of a 3.5 GPA on admission to a state college is additional influenced by components reminiscent of the scholar’s highschool curriculum rigor, standardized take a look at scores (if required), and the particular program to which the scholar is making use of. Sure departments, reminiscent of engineering or nursing, might have increased GPA expectations than others. Moreover, state universities usually contemplate residency standing, giving desire to in-state candidates. For instance, a pupil from out-of-state with a 3.5 GPA making use of to a state college would possibly face a better admission hurdle in comparison with an in-state pupil with the identical GPA, on account of restricted areas for non-residents and the college’s mission to serve the state’s inhabitants.

In abstract, a 3.5 GPA is mostly a good attribute when making use of to state universities, though the probability of admission depends upon the college’s selectivity, the applicant’s total profile, and the particular program of curiosity. Whereas a 3.5 GPA alone doesn’t assure acceptance, it positions the applicant inside a aggressive vary at many state establishments. Understanding these nuances permits potential college students to strategically goal their purposes and optimize their probabilities of admission. Navigating the complexities of state college admissions requires thorough analysis and a sensible evaluation of 1’s educational standing in relation to the particular college’s admission standards.

2. Liberal Arts Schools

Liberal arts schools, recognized for his or her emphasis on broad-based training and demanding considering abilities, usually contemplate a 3.5 GPA as a good indicator of a pupil’s educational potential. Whereas these establishments usually make use of a holistic overview course of, a 3.5 GPA could be a vital asset within the software.

  • Holistic Evaluate Course of

    Liberal arts schools usually prioritize a holistic analysis of candidates, contemplating components past numerical metrics reminiscent of GPA and standardized take a look at scores. This encompasses essays, letters of advice, extracurricular actions, and demonstrated curiosity. A 3.5 GPA can function a baseline indicator of educational competence, permitting the admissions committee to deal with different facets of the applicant’s profile. As an illustration, a pupil with a 3.5 GPA coupled with robust management expertise in extracurricular actions could also be considered extra favorably than a pupil with a barely increased GPA however minimal involvement exterior of teachers.

  • Emphasis on Writing and Communication Expertise

    Liberal arts schools place a robust emphasis on written and oral communication abilities. A 3.5 GPA usually displays a pupil’s proficiency in these areas, as educational coursework usually requires efficient writing and communication. Moreover, software essays present a possibility for college kids to reveal their writing talents and articulate their distinctive views. A well-written essay can considerably improve an applicant’s possibilities, even when their GPA is barely under the common for admitted college students. Conversely, a poorly written essay can detract from an in any other case robust software, whatever the GPA.

  • Small Class Sizes and School Interplay

    The small class sizes and shut faculty-student interplay attribute of liberal arts schools necessitate a robust work ethic and the power to interact in mental discourse. A 3.5 GPA suggests {that a} pupil possesses the tutorial basis and motivation to thrive on this surroundings. Moreover, letters of advice from lecturers can present worthwhile insights right into a pupil’s classroom participation, essential considering abilities, and total mental curiosity, additional complementing the GPA as an indicator of educational potential.

  • Institutional Priorities and Mission

    Every liberal arts school has its personal distinctive mission and institutional priorities, which may affect admission selections. Some schools might prioritize college students from underrepresented backgrounds, whereas others might deal with attracting college students with particular skills or pursuits. Due to this fact, the influence of a 3.5 GPA can differ relying on the particular school and its targets. As an illustration, a pupil with a demonstrated ardour for group service and a 3.5 GPA could also be significantly enticing to a liberal arts school with a robust dedication to social justice, even when their GPA is barely decrease than the common for admitted college students.

In abstract, whereas a 3.5 GPA is a optimistic attribute within the admissions course of at liberal arts schools, it’s only one issue amongst many which can be thought of. These establishments emphasize a holistic analysis of candidates, considering components reminiscent of writing abilities, extracurricular involvement, and alignment with the school’s mission. A pupil with a 3.5 GPA who can reveal robust communication abilities, mental curiosity, and a dedication to non-public development is prone to be a aggressive applicant at many liberal arts schools.

3. Take a look at-Elective Insurance policies

Take a look at-optional insurance policies have considerably altered the panorama of school admissions, impacting the relative significance of GPA. Establishments adopting these insurance policies place better emphasis on different components of the applying, together with educational efficiency mirrored by GPA. A 3.5 GPA, on this context, can develop into a extra central indicator of a pupil’s capabilities.

  • Elevated Emphasis on GPA

    When standardized take a look at scores usually are not required or thought of, the GPA takes on better weight as a measure of educational achievement. A 3.5 GPA, due to this fact, indicators constant efficiency in coursework, changing into a key information level for admissions committees. For instance, a pupil with a 3.5 GPA at a test-optional establishment might have a extra aggressive software than a pupil with a decrease GPA and robust take a look at scores, as the previous’s educational consistency is extra readily obvious.

  • Holistic Software Evaluate

    Take a look at-optional insurance policies usually coincide with a extra holistic strategy to software overview. Which means essays, letters of advice, and extracurricular actions are given better consideration. A 3.5 GPA serves as a basis upon which these different components are evaluated. As an illustration, a compelling essay that highlights a pupil’s mental curiosity, coupled with a 3.5 GPA, can reveal a robust educational profile regardless of the absence of standardized take a look at scores.

  • Accessibility and Fairness

    Take a look at-optional insurance policies purpose to advertise better accessibility and fairness within the admissions course of. Standardized exams have been proven to correlate with socioeconomic standing, probably disadvantaging college students from lower-income backgrounds. By de-emphasizing take a look at scores, establishments can deal with GPA as a extra equitable measure of educational potential. A 3.5 GPA, due to this fact, permits proficient college students from various backgrounds to realize admission based mostly on their demonstrated classroom efficiency.

  • Institutional Context and Selectivity

    The influence of a 3.5 GPA in a test-optional surroundings depends upon the establishment’s selectivity. Extremely selective establishments should still view a 3.5 GPA at the least threshold, whereas much less selective establishments might discover it a robust indicator of educational readiness. Due to this fact, college students ought to analysis the particular GPA ranges of admitted college students at their goal establishments, even when take a look at scores usually are not required. Understanding this context permits for a extra strategic strategy to school purposes.

In conclusion, test-optional insurance policies elevate the significance of GPA as a major indicator of educational functionality. A 3.5 GPA, coupled with different software parts, can present a robust basis for admission at many schools. Nevertheless, college students ought to nonetheless contemplate the selectivity and particular admissions standards of every establishment to optimize their software technique. The transfer in direction of test-optional admissions has created new alternatives for college kids to showcase their educational achievements via GPA and different qualitative components.

4. Holistic Evaluate Course of

The holistic overview course of, a way of evaluating school purposes, considers an applicant’s experiences and attributes alongside educational metrics. This strategy supplies context to numerical values, reminiscent of a 3.5 GPA, permitting admissions committees to evaluate potential past grade level common alone.

  • Contextualizing Educational Efficiency

    The holistic overview course of examines an applicant’s educational file in relation to their particular person circumstances. Components such because the rigor of coursework, entry to sources, and private challenges are thought of. A 3.5 GPA from a pupil who overcame vital obstacles could also be considered extra favorably than an analogous GPA from a pupil with considerable sources. The overview seeks to know how the GPA displays educational potential inside a particular context.

  • Assessing Non-Educational Attributes

    Holistic overview locations worth on non-academic qualities, together with management abilities, group involvement, and distinctive skills. These attributes are assessed via essays, letters of advice, and extracurricular actions. A 3.5 GPA, coupled with demonstrated management or a novel talent set, can improve an applicant’s profile, indicating a well-rounded particular person with potential for contribution to the school group.

  • Evaluating Private Essays and Suggestions

    The private essay supplies a possibility for candidates to articulate their experiences, values, and aspirations. Letters of advice supply insights into an applicant’s character, work ethic, and potential for achievement. A 3.5 GPA, complemented by compelling essays and supportive suggestions, can paint a extra full image of an applicant’s capabilities and readiness for college-level work. The narrative components of the applying can illuminate the scholar’s perspective and dedication past the numerical illustration of educational achievement.

  • Aligning with Institutional Mission and Values

    Schools using holistic overview usually search college students who align with their particular mission and values. A 3.5 GPA, along side demonstrated dedication to service, inventive expression, or different institutional priorities, can strengthen an applicant’s candidacy. The overview course of goals to create a various and engaged pupil physique that displays the school’s ethos and contributes to its distinctive studying surroundings.

The holistic overview course of, due to this fact, supplies a nuanced understanding of an applicant’s potential, complementing the knowledge conveyed by a 3.5 GPA. This strategy permits schools to think about a broader vary of {qualifications} and create a various and dynamic pupil physique.

5. Main Competitiveness

The competitiveness of a selected educational main considerably influences the load a university locations on a 3.5 GPA through the admissions course of. Sure fields of examine, reminiscent of engineering, laptop science, or pre-med applications, usually appeal to a bigger pool of extremely certified candidates. This heightened demand usually leads to stricter admission standards, the place a 3.5 GPA, whereas representing a strong educational file, will not be ample to ensure acceptance. Conversely, much less sought-after majors would possibly contemplate a 3.5 GPA extra favorably, offered the applicant meets different admission necessities.

As an illustration, a pupil making use of to a highly-ranked engineering program at a aggressive college might discover that the common GPA of admitted college students is nearer to three.7 or increased. In such circumstances, supplemental components, reminiscent of superior placement coursework, related extracurricular actions (e.g., robotics membership), and robust letters of advice from science and math lecturers, develop into essential in differentiating the applicant. Nevertheless, a pupil making use of to a much less aggressive main inside the identical college may need a better likelihood of acceptance with a 3.5 GPA, significantly in the event that they reveal a real ardour for the topic and possess robust writing abilities as evidenced by their software essays.

In abstract, the impact of a 3.5 GPA on school admissions is inextricably linked to main competitiveness. Potential college students ought to analysis the particular GPA expectations for his or her supposed discipline of examine at every goal establishment. This understanding permits them to evaluate their possibilities realistically and strategically strengthen their purposes, specializing in areas past GPA to reinforce their total candidacy. Recognizing {that a} 3.5 GPA is a relative metric inside the context of main choice is essential for navigating the school admissions course of successfully.

6. Extracurricular Actions

Extracurricular actions maintain vital weight in school admissions, significantly for candidates with a 3.5 GPA. Whereas a 3.5 GPA signifies strong educational efficiency, extracurricular involvement supplies a broader image of the scholar’s character, pursuits, and potential contributions to the school group. Schools search well-rounded people who reveal management, teamwork, and a dedication to non-public development past the classroom. Due to this fact, robust participation in extracurriculars can elevate the general software and probably compensate for a GPA that isn’t on the very high of the applicant pool. For instance, a pupil with a 3.5 GPA who’s a captain of a sports activities staff, actively volunteers of their group, or participates in debate membership demonstrates worthwhile abilities and qualities that admissions committees worth.

The influence of extracurriculars is just not merely about amount but additionally high quality and depth of involvement. Sustained dedication to some significant actions is mostly considered extra favorably than superficial participation in quite a few golf equipment or organizations. Admissions officers search for proof of ardour, dedication, and a willingness to tackle management roles. A pupil who has persistently volunteered at an area animal shelter for a number of years, demonstrating compassion and accountability, will doubtless make a stronger impression than somebody who briefly joined a number of golf equipment with out making a major contribution. Moreover, participation in actions that align with a pupil’s supposed main can additional strengthen their software, demonstrating a real curiosity within the discipline.

In abstract, whereas a 3.5 GPA establishes a baseline of educational competence, extracurricular actions function a essential differentiator within the school admissions course of. They supply proof of a pupil’s character, management potential, and dedication to non-public development. Due to this fact, college students with a 3.5 GPA ought to prioritize significant involvement in actions that align with their pursuits and passions, demonstrating their skill to contribute to the school group past their educational efficiency. The mixture of strong grades and robust extracurriculars creates a compelling narrative that may considerably improve a pupil’s probabilities of admission.

7. Software Power

Software energy is a multifaceted idea that considerably influences school admission selections, significantly for candidates with a 3.5 GPA. Whereas a 3.5 GPA is a optimistic indicator, the general energy of the applying determines whether or not it’s ample for admission to a particular establishment. A compelling software showcases a pupil’s potential, character, and match with the school’s mission and values.

  • Essays and Private Statements

    Essays and private statements present a story that contextualizes the applicant’s educational file and divulges their persona, motivations, and targets. These written items supply an area to elaborate on experiences which have formed the applicant’s perspective and reveal essential considering and writing abilities. A well-crafted essay can spotlight a pupil’s resilience, mental curiosity, or distinctive skills, thereby elevating the applying past the numerical worth of a 3.5 GPA. As an illustration, a pupil who has overcome private challenges or demonstrated distinctive management in extracurricular actions can use the essay to articulate their development and potential contribution to the school group.

  • Letters of Advice

    Letters of advice from lecturers, counselors, or mentors supply insights into the applicant’s character, work ethic, and potential for achievement in school. These letters present a third-party perspective on the scholar’s educational talents, private qualities, and contributions to the classroom or group. Sturdy letters of advice can validate the scholar’s strengths and supply context for any perceived weaknesses within the software. A instructor who can attest to a pupil’s mental curiosity, perseverance, or collaborative abilities can considerably improve the applying’s total energy, even with a 3.5 GPA.

  • Course Rigor and Educational Traits

    The rigor of the applicant’s highschool curriculum and their educational efficiency over time are necessary components in assessing software energy. Schools contemplate the kinds of programs taken (e.g., honors, AP, IB) and the grades earned in these programs. A 3.5 GPA achieved in a difficult curriculum could also be considered extra favorably than an analogous GPA earned in much less rigorous coursework. Moreover, an upward pattern in grades, demonstrating enchancment over time, can point out development and potential. Schools wish to see that candidates have challenged themselves academically and have persistently carried out nicely in a demanding surroundings.

  • Demonstrated Curiosity and Match

    Demonstrating real curiosity in a selected school and showcasing a transparent understanding of its mission, values, and educational applications can strengthen an software. Candidates can reveal curiosity by visiting the campus, attending digital occasions, participating with alumni, or articulating a transparent rationale for why they’re a very good match for the establishment. A pupil with a 3.5 GPA who has actively researched the school’s choices and might articulate how their abilities and pursuits align with the school’s applications and group will doubtless make a stronger impression than somebody who submits a generic software.

In essence, software energy encompasses a holistic analysis of an applicant’s qualities and experiences, going past the numerical illustration of a 3.5 GPA. By crafting a compelling narrative, securing robust letters of advice, pursuing a rigorous curriculum, and demonstrating real curiosity within the school, candidates can considerably improve their probabilities of admission. Schools search college students who usually are not solely academically succesful but additionally well-rounded, engaged, and dedicated to contributing to the campus group. The energy of the applying, due to this fact, turns into the important thing determinant in whether or not a 3.5 GPA is ample for admission.

8. Monetary Support Availability

Monetary support availability is intrinsically linked to the query of which schools settle for a 3.5 GPA. Whereas a 3.5 GPA can unlock admission to a variety of establishments, the accessibility of these establishments is commonly contingent upon the supply of monetary help. For college students from decrease socioeconomic backgrounds, even acceptance to a school is rendered moot if the related prices are prohibitive. Due to this fact, the monetary support insurance policies and sources of a school immediately influence its true accessibility, no matter GPA-based acceptance charges. A pupil with a 3.5 GPA could also be admitted to a prestigious personal college, but when the accessible monetary support bundle doesn’t adequately cowl tuition and dwelling bills, the scholar might finally select to attend a much less selective however extra inexpensive state college. Thus, monetary support availability could be a deciding issue, successfully shaping the panorama of “what schools settle for a 3.5 GPA” in a sensible sense.

A number of components affect the monetary support equation. Some schools have massive endowments and are in a position to supply beneficiant need-based support packages, successfully lowering the monetary burden on admitted college students. Different establishments might rely extra closely on merit-based scholarships, rewarding high-achieving college students with substantial monetary help. Moreover, federal and state monetary support applications, reminiscent of Pell Grants and state-specific grants, play a essential position in bridging the affordability hole for a lot of college students. The mixture of institutional support, merit-based scholarships, and authorities grants can considerably influence the online value of attendance, ensuring schools extra accessible than others, even when their preliminary sticker value seems daunting. For instance, a pupil accepted to 2 schools, one providing a full-ride scholarship and the opposite requiring vital out-of-pocket bills, will doubtless prioritize the previous, whatever the latter’s perceived status or selectivity.

In conclusion, whereas a 3.5 GPA opens doorways to quite a few schools, the sensible actuality of attending these establishments hinges on monetary support availability. The generosity of a school’s monetary support insurance policies, coupled with federal and state help applications, determines the true affordability and accessibility for college kids. Understanding the interaction between acceptance charges based mostly on GPA and the monetary support panorama is essential for college kids and households navigating the school choice course of. The problem lies in not solely securing admission but additionally guaranteeing that the chosen establishment supplies sufficient monetary help to make increased training a viable and sustainable funding. The true reply to “what schools settle for a 3.5 GPA” is due to this fact formed by a mixture of educational achievement and monetary feasibility.

Regularly Requested Questions

The next addresses widespread inquiries relating to school admissions with a grade level common of three.5. These solutions present readability on navigating the applying course of and understanding the context surrounding GPA.

Query 1: Is a 3.5 GPA ample for admission to a selective college?

A 3.5 GPA supplies a strong basis for school purposes; nonetheless, admission to extremely selective universities usually requires a extra complete profile. Supplemental components, reminiscent of standardized take a look at scores (if required), rigorous coursework, compelling essays, and impactful extracurricular actions, develop into essential for standing out amongst a aggressive applicant pool.

Query 2: How does test-optional admissions influence the worth of a 3.5 GPA?

Take a look at-optional insurance policies usually improve the relative significance of GPA. With out standardized take a look at scores for comparability, schools place better emphasis on GPA as an indicator of educational efficiency. A 3.5 GPA can due to this fact be a major asset in a test-optional surroundings, demonstrating constant educational achievement.

Query 3: Does the rigor of highschool coursework have an effect on the notion of a 3.5 GPA?

Sure, schools contemplate the rigor of highschool coursework when evaluating a 3.5 GPA. A GPA earned in superior placement (AP) or Worldwide Baccalaureate (IB) programs is mostly considered extra favorably than the identical GPA earned in standard-level programs, because it demonstrates a willingness to problem oneself academically.

Query 4: How necessary are extracurricular actions for candidates with a 3.5 GPA?

Extracurricular actions play a significant position in demonstrating a pupil’s pursuits, abilities, and character. Significant involvement in extracurriculars, significantly management roles or sustained dedication to a trigger, can considerably improve an software, offering proof of qualities past educational achievement.

Query 5: Can a robust software essay compensate for a 3.5 GPA at a aggressive school?

A compelling software essay can certainly strengthen an software with a 3.5 GPA. The essay supplies a possibility to showcase distinctive experiences, views, and writing talents. A well-crafted essay can spotlight private development, resilience, or mental curiosity, thereby making a extra nuanced and favorable impression.

Query 6: Does the supposed main have an effect on admission prospects with a 3.5 GPA?

The competitiveness of the supposed main considerably influences admission prospects. Extremely sought-after majors, reminiscent of engineering or laptop science, usually have increased GPA expectations. Candidates to those applications might have extra {qualifications}, reminiscent of related expertise or superior coursework, to compensate for a 3.5 GPA.

A 3.5 GPA represents a commendable educational achievement, opening doorways to a big selection of schools. Understanding the context surrounding this GPA together with test-optional insurance policies, course rigor, extracurricular involvement, and main competitiveness is essential for navigating the school admissions course of successfully.

The next part will discover methods for maximizing the potential of a 3.5 GPA within the school software course of.

Maximizing the Potential of a 3.5 GPA

A 3.5 GPA represents a strong educational basis, however strategic planning is important to maximise its influence on school admissions. The next ideas supply steering for candidates aiming to reinforce their prospects with this grade level common.

Tip 1: Emphasize Course Rigor: Persistently pursue difficult coursework, together with superior placement (AP) or Worldwide Baccalaureate (IB) lessons, the place accessible. Success in rigorous programs demonstrates a dedication to educational excellence and enhances the notion of a 3.5 GPA.

Tip 2: Domesticate Significant Extracurricular Involvement: Deal with just a few extracurricular actions and pursue them with ardour and dedication. Search management alternatives and attempt to make a tangible influence inside the chosen actions. Depth of involvement is mostly extra valued than breadth.

Tip 3: Craft Compelling Essays: Strategy the applying essay as a possibility to showcase distinctive experiences, views, and writing abilities. Inform a narrative that reveals character, resilience, or mental curiosity. The essay is an opportunity to contextualize the GPA and spotlight private qualities.

Tip 4: Safe Sturdy Letters of Advice: Domesticate optimistic relationships with lecturers and counselors who can present insightful and supportive letters of advice. Present recommenders with ample details about educational achievements and extracurricular actions to allow them to jot down personalised and compelling endorsements.

Tip 5: Analysis Goal Schools Totally: Examine the common GPA and standardized take a look at scores (if required) of admitted college students at goal schools. Perceive the establishment’s mission, values, and educational applications to articulate a transparent rationale for why it’s a good match. Demonstrated curiosity can positively affect admission selections.

Tip 6: Tackle Weaknesses Transparently: If there are any weaknesses within the educational file (e.g., a low grade in a selected course), tackle them transparently within the software. Present context or rationalization with out making excuses. Demonstrating self-awareness and a willingness to study from errors may be considered positively.

Tip 7: Take into account Take a look at-Elective Methods Rigorously: If making use of to test-optional schools, rigorously weigh the choice of whether or not or to not submit standardized take a look at scores. If the scores are considerably decrease than the school’s common, it could be advantageous to omit them. Deal with highlighting different strengths within the software, reminiscent of GPA, coursework, and essays.

By implementing these methods, candidates with a 3.5 GPA can strengthen their school purposes and improve their probabilities of admission to their desired establishments. A proactive and strategic strategy to the applying course of can successfully showcase a pupil’s potential and character.

The conclusion of this exploration will synthesize the important thing insights and supply ultimate suggestions for college kids navigating the school admissions panorama with a 3.5 GPA.

Conclusion

The previous evaluation has explored the nuances of “what schools settle for a 3.5 gpa,” revealing that this educational standing supplies entry to a broad spectrum of establishments. The acceptance panorama, nonetheless, is just not solely decided by GPA. Components reminiscent of standardized take a look at insurance policies, curriculum rigor, extracurricular engagement, software energy, main competitiveness, and monetary support availability every play a essential position in shaping admissions outcomes. A strategic strategy, specializing in holistic software growth and focused school choice, is paramount.

Understanding these complexities empowers potential college students to navigate the school admissions course of with better readability and function. Whereas a 3.5 GPA represents a strong educational basis, the final word willpower of school acceptance rests on a confluence of things, requiring diligent preparation and a complete understanding of particular person institutional priorities. Continued analysis and proactive engagement stay important for reaching profitable placement in increased training.

Leave a Comment